Search Site
Main Office : 125 St Pauls Blvd, Ste 510, Norfolk, Virginia 23510   |   8 Hampton Roads Meeting Locations
Free Consultation Call or Text 24/7 757.455.0077
$500,000 Settlement for Injured Sailor
$500,000 Settlement for Injured Sailor

As your lawyer, I do everything in my power to get you results.- Jim Hurley

Attorney at Cooper Hurley Injury Lawyers

$500,000 settlement for an injured sailor who fell from an unsafe ladder on a ship and suffered a mild traumatic brain injury, knee, neck and back injuries.



John Cooper and Bill O’Mara


A 32-year-old assistant-steward was working on a U.S. government owned vessel that was operated by a civilian contractor. Instead of a Jones Act case, the matter was handled under separate maritime law where the worker, although not in the military, was working for a big, international firm under contract to provide seamen for a military ship.

Our female client was a union employee aboard the ship when she fell in her stateroom as she retrieved papers from the upper bunk. She claimed that proper anti-skid tape had not been applied to a rung used on the ladder to access the bed.

The seaman struck her head on the ship floor and hit her knee on the ladder rung as she fell. She was diagnosed with a mild traumatic brain injury and required arthroscopic surgery for her knee. She also sustained neck and back injuries. Our client suffered ongoing cognitive impairment and chronic PTSD (Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder) symptoms. Her damages included a loss of future earnings in the well-paying field of being a crew member on a vessel.

We filed a lawsuit against the U.S. government under the Public Vessels Act and the Suits in Admiralty Act for maritime claims. The defendant alleged it was not negligent because the ladder system was properly installed during a retrofit of the ship. It said the injured worker never complained about the safety of the bunk or the ladder. The defendant claimed comparative fault was a factor because the assistant-steward admitted that she believed the ladder system was hazardous before she fell, but felt she had no choice but to use it.

Additionally, a large legal battle arose under the doctrine of governmental immunity for discretionary functions. As with the Federal Tort Claims Act, there is a wide exception to the waiver of sovereign immunity where the discretionary functions of government are used to make decisions about how to do certain tasks to fulfill government policy.

The civilian company providing the non-military crew for the vessel said the retrofit of the bunk access was ordered by the military as a part of federal policy and could not be second-guessed. We argued that the case involved routine maintenance and the failure to rectify the problems when the plaintiff complained to her superiors.

This body of law is extremely specific and would have completely barred recovery if the federal court found in favor of the defense on the issue. The matter was briefed but never ruled upon.

This maritime case involved some extremely complex areas of law. The Cooper Hurley team gathered evidence from a range of experts including a psychiatrist, a traumatic brain injury specialist, a neuropsychologist, an orthopedist, and vocational, economic and maritime procedure experts.


The case was resolved via negotiations with the experienced maritime defense attorneys for the U.S. government about 45 days before a trial in U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Virginia, Norfolk Division. The plaintiff received a settlement of $500,000 plus maintenance and cure through the time of the agreement.

John Cooper

John Cooper is a veteran of personal injury law practice in Virginia. A native Virginian, he was raised in Norfolk and Virginia Beach. He has more than 20 years of experience handling personal injury cases and recently handled the largest auto accident settlement in 2010, according to VA Lawyers Weekly. The award provided $3.5 million to a child whose young father died when the vehicle he was a passenger in was rear-ended by a careless truck driver.

View Full Bio
Jim Hurley

Jim Hurley has been practicing law throughout Virginia for more than two-and-a-half decades. During his career, he has tried more than 100 jury trials — a staggering number — and handled hundreds more that were settled out of court. He is guided by the principle that the client is in charge of his or her case and should be kept fully aware of the litigation process. Jim has been awarded an AV Rating by Martindale-Hubbell, the highest rating given, for his practice of law. He was named in Virginia Super Lawyers in 2014, 2015, 2016.

View Full Bio
Bill O’mara

Bill O’Mara started his legal career in 2008, moving back to his home town of Chesapeake, VA. He has practiced in the field of plaintiffs’ personal injury and other litigation. He has gained extensive court room and trial experience, including contested trials before judges and juries across Hampton Roads. In 2014, Mr. O’Mara joined Injury Lawyers as an associate attorney. He became a partner in 2017.

View Full Bio
    • VOTED BEST OF 2018!

      Cooper Hurley Injury Lawyers voted Best Law Firm in Norfolk.

      Thank you Hampton Roads!

      Read More
    • Recent Blogs Injuries at Daycares in Virginia Spark Oversight Concerns

      Our children are precious but we often have to put them in the care of others from an early age, whether at schools or daycares…. Read More »


      Read More
    • Download our FREE e-books

      At Cooper Hurley Injury Lawyers, we understand that the law is confusing. Learn about what to do after an accident. Explore our collection of FREE e-books.

      View Free E-Books
    • 2019 Scholarship Award

      Cooper Hurley Injury Lawyers awards three $2,000 college scholarships annually to high school seniors in the Tidewater and Eastern Shore areas of Virginia. Eligible students can submit an essay of 500 to 1,000 words on the subject of Distracted Driving. We established this program to aid worthy scholars and to raise awareness of the tragic consequences of distracted driving, which we encounter too often in our practice.

      Learn More
    Contact Us

    Please fill out form below and one of our attorneys will contact you.

    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
    8 Hampton Roads Meeting Locations

    Use the map below to find the location closest to you

    View more